27 Key Metrics for Measuring the Success of Your Online Member Community

Updated: 05/09/2024

Building and managing a thriving online community is no small feat. To ensure your community is growing, actively engaging, and converting, it’s essential to track the right metrics. Below, we break down the key performance indicators (KPIs) into three main categories: Membership & Growth, Activity, and Conversion. Each category highlights the metrics that will help you gauge the health and success of your online community.

In this Post:


Membership & Growth Metrics

Understanding your community’s growth is crucial. These metrics help you monitor its expansion over time and identify trends that may need attention.

1: Number of Community Members

  • Definition: The total number of individuals who have joined your community.
  • Purpose: Provides a snapshot of your community’s overall size.
  • Goal: A larger community size indicates growth and appeal.
  • Benchmark: Aim for a steady monthly increase in total members.
  • Formula: Count of registered members.

2: Number of New Community Members

  • Definition: The number of new members who have joined your community within a specific time frame.
  • Purpose: Measures the effectiveness of your outreach and recruitment strategies.
  • Goal: More new members each month suggests successful growth initiatives.
  • Benchmark: Target a 5-10% increase in new members month-over-month.
  • Formula: Count of new member registrations within the defined period.

3: Number of Churned or Deactivated Members

  • Definition: The number of members who have left or deactivated their accounts.
  • Purpose: Identifies potential issues with member satisfaction and retention.
  • Goal: Lower churn rates are better, indicating strong member retention.
  • Benchmark: Aim for less than 5% churn per month.
  • Formula: Count of deactivated or removed member accounts.

4: Month-over-Month Membership Growth

  • Definition: The percentage increase or decrease in the number of community members compared to the previous month.
  • Purpose: Tracks the overall growth trend of your community.
  • Goal: Positive growth month-over-month signals a healthy community.
  • Benchmark: A monthly growth rate of 5-10% is ideal.
  • Formula: ((Current Month Members – Previous Month Members) / Previous Month Members) x 100.

5: Percentage of Retained New Members

  • Definition: The percentage of new members who remain active after a set period (e.g., one month).
  • Purpose: Assess the effectiveness of your onboarding process.
  • Goal: Higher retention rates indicate a successful onboarding experience.
  • Benchmark: Aim for a 70% retention rate for new members after one month.
  • Formula: (Number of New Members Retained / Total Number of New Members) x 100.

6: Percentage of Membership Churn

  • Definition: The percentage of members who leave or deactivate their accounts compared to the total number of members.
  • Purpose: Provides insight into how well you are retaining your community members.
  • Goal: Lower churn percentages indicate better retention.
  • Benchmark: Keep churn below 5% monthly.
  • Formula: (Number of Churned Members / Total Number of Members) x 100.

Community Activity Metrics

Once members join, their activity within the community becomes a key indicator of engagement. The following metrics will help you understand how active your members are and where they are most engaged.

1: Number of Total Community Members

  • Definition: The total count of members in your community, considering active and inactive members.
  • Purpose: Helps in evaluating the potential reach and participation in the community.
  • Goal: A large total membership base provides more opportunities for engagement.
  • Benchmark: Track alongside active members to understand the engagement ratio.
  • Formula: Count of all registered community members.

2: Number of Member Logins

  • Definition: The number of times members log in to the community within a specific period.
  • Purpose: Indicates how often members are engaging with the community.
  • Goal: More frequent logins suggest a highly engaged community.
  • Benchmark: Monitor for trends; a consistent increase is ideal.
  • Formula: Count of member logins over the defined period.

3: Number of Member Pageviews

  • Definition: The total number of pages viewed by members of the community.
  • Purpose: Gauges the level of content consumption within the community.
  • Goal: Higher page views indicate active exploration and engagement.
  • Benchmark: Aim for an increase in page views as content offerings grow.
  • Formula: Count of pageviews generated by members.

4: Number of Member Posts

  • Definition: The number of posts created by members within the community.
  • Purpose: Tracks the level of content contribution by members.
  • Goal: An increase in posts indicates a vibrant and engaged community.
  • Benchmark: Encourage a 10-15% increase in monthly member posts.
  • Formula: Count of posts created by members.

5: Number of Member Comments/Replies

  • Definition: The number of comments or replies made by members on posts.
  • Purpose: Measures interaction and engagement between community members.
  • Goal: More comments and replies indicate a high level of member interaction.
  • Benchmark: Monitor for consistent or increasing engagement.
  • Formula: Count of member comments and replies.

6: Number of Groups

  • Definition: The total number of groups created within the community.
  • Purpose: Reflects the diversity of interests within the community.
  • Goal: More groups suggest a broader range of member interests and interactions.
  • Benchmark: Track the growth in groups alongside active group participation.
  • Formula: Count of groups created in the community.

7: Average Time Spent in Community

  • Definition: The average time members spend in the community during each visit.
  • Formula: Total time spent by all members / Total number of visits.
  • Purpose: Indicates how engaging and valuable the community is to its members.
  • Goal: Longer time spent suggests deeper engagement.
  • Benchmark: Aim for a consistent increase in average session duration.

8: Number of Active Members

  • Definition: The number of members actively participating in the community within a specific period.
  • Purpose: Tracks the active engagement level within the community.
  • Goal: More active members indicate a lively and engaging community.
  • Benchmark: Aim for at least 50% of members to be active regularly.
  • Formula: Count of members who meet the activity criteria (e.g., login, posting, commenting).

9: Number of Active Groups

  • Definition: The number of groups that see regular activity, such as posts or discussions.
  • Purpose: Helps identify which segments of the community are most engaged.
  • Goal: More active groups indicate a dynamic and diverse community.
  • Benchmark: Aim for at least 60-70% of groups to be active.
  • Formula: Count of groups with regular activity.

10: Percentage of Active Members

  • Definition: The percentage of total members who are active within the community.
  • Purpose: Provides a clear view of engagement levels.
  • Goal: Higher percentages indicate strong community involvement.
  • Benchmark: Aim for 50-60% of members to be active regularly.
  • Formula: (Number of Active Members / Total Number of Members) x 100.

11: Percentage of Total Groups that Are Active

  • Definition: The percentage of groups that members actively use.
  • Purpose: Reflects the engagement and vibrancy of your community’s group discussions.
  • Goal: Higher percentages mean more diverse and engaged discussions.
  • Benchmark: Target at least 60% of groups to be active.
  • Formula: (Number of Active Groups / Total Number of Groups) x 100.

Community Conversion Metrics

Engagement is great, but what about actions that lead to actual results? Conversion metrics focus on those actions that show how well your community drives member behaviour towards specific goals.

1: Number of Event Registrations

    • Definition: The number of members who register for events your community hosts.
    • Purpose: Indicates how appealing and relevant your events are to members.
    • Goal: Higher registration numbers suggest strong member interest.
    • Benchmark: Aim for a consistent increase in event registrations over time.
    • Formula: Count of event registrations.

2: Number of Resource Downloads

    • Definition: The number of times members download resources such as guides, e-books, or templates.
    • Purpose: Tracks how valuable your content is to the community.
    • Goal: More downloads indicate that your resources are in demand.
    • Benchmark: Monitor for steady growth in downloads as more resources are offered.
    • Formula: Count of resource downloads by members.

3: Number of Videos Viewed

    • Definition: The total number of video views by members within the community.
    • Purpose: Measures the engagement and reach of video content.
    • Goal: Higher view counts suggest that video content is resonating with members.
    • Benchmark: Track views to ensure video content remains engaging.
    • Formula: Count of video views.

4: Number of Donations Made

    • Definition: The total number of donations made by community members.
    • Purpose: Indicates members’ support and commitment to your community’s cause.
    • Goal: More donations reflect more substantial member commitment.
    • Benchmark: Aim for a steady increase in donations as the community grows.
    • Formula: Count of donations made by members.

5: Number of Information/Profile Updates Made

    • Definition: The number of times members update their personal information or profiles.
    • Purpose: Reflects member engagement and their interest in maintaining an active profile.
    • Goal: Higher update rates indicate members are invested in their community presence.
    • Benchmark: Track updates to monitor engagement levels.
    • Formula: Count of profile or information updates made by members.

6: Number of Purchases Made

    • Definition: The total number of purchases made by community members.
    • Purpose: Measures the community’s effectiveness as a sales channel.
    • Goal: More purchases suggest that members find value in the products or services offered.
    • Benchmark: Monitor purchase trends to identify growth opportunities.
    • Formula: Count of purchases made by members.

7: Number of Members Who [Insert Specific Action Here]

    • Definition: The count of members who complete a specific action necessary to your community’s goals.
    • Purpose: Tracks particular behaviours that contribute to your community’s success.
    • Goal: Higher numbers indicate greater engagement with targeted actions.
    • Benchmark: Set specific benchmarks based on the importance of the action.
    • Formula: Count of members completing the particular action.

8: Number of Members Who [Take Multiple Actions]

    • Definition: The count of members who engage in multiple actions, showing high levels of involvement.
    • Purpose: Identifies the most engaged members interacting with various aspects of the community.
    • Goal: More multi-action members indicate deeper engagement.
    • Benchmark: Track this to identify your most engaged members.
    • Formula: Count of members who take multiple actions.

9: Percentage of Total Members Who Undertake a Specific Action

    • Definition: The percentage of your total membership that completes a specific action.
    • Purpose: Provides insight into how widespread a particular behaviour is within your community.
    • Goal: Higher percentages reflect more substantial alignment with community goals.
    • Benchmark: Set benchmarks based on the action’s strategic importance.
    • Formula: (Number of Members Undertaking Specific Action / Total Members) x 100.

10: Percentage of Total Members Who Undertake Multiple Actions

    • Definition: The percentage of your total membership that engages in multiple actions.
    • Purpose: Indicates the overall engagement level across different activities in the community.
    • Goal: Higher percentages mean more members are deeply involved.
    • Benchmark: Track to ensure a growing proportion of your community is highly engaged.
    • Formula: (Number of Members Undertaking Multiple Actions / Total Members) x 100.

Conclusion

Tracking these metrics will give you a comprehensive view of your online community’s health. By understanding growth, activity, and conversion patterns, you can make informed decisions to foster a more vibrant, engaging, and thriving community.

Chief Tea Boy and Marketeer

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Don't forget to share!

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Related Reading